What kind of water freezes faster, hot or cold, many factors affect, but the question itself seems a bit strange. It is also understood, and this is known from physics that hot water still needs time to cool down to a temperature compared cold waterTo turn into ice. With cold water, this stage can be skipped, and, accordingly, it wins on time.

But the answer to the question of what water freezes faster - cold or hot - on the street in Frost, any resident of northern latitudes knows. In essence, scientifically, it turns out that in any case, cold water is simply obliged to freeze faster.

The teacher of physics, to which a schoolboy Erasto Mpembea addressed in 1963 to explain why a cold mixture of future ice cream freezes longer than similar, but hot.

"This is not a world physics, but some kind of physics MPEMB"

At that time, the teacher only laughed at this, but Denss Osborne, Professor of Physics, who at one time drove into the same school, where he studied Erassto, experimentally confirmed the presence of such an effect, although there was no explanation then to this. In 1969, a joint article of these two people was published in the popular scientific journal, which described this peculiar effect.

Since then, by the way, the question of what water freezes is freezing - hot or cold, has its own name - the effect, or paradox, scam.

The question arose long ago

Naturally, before such a phenomenon had a place to be, and he was mentioned in the works of other scientists. Not only a schoolboy was interested in this issue, but he was thinking about this René Descartes and even Aristotle.

But only approaches to the decision of this paradox have begun to look only at the end of the twentieth century.

Conditions in order to have a paradox

As in the case of ice cream, not just ordinary water freezes during the experiment. There must be certain conditions in order to start arguing which water freezes faster - cold or hot. What affects the course of this process?

Now, in the 21st century, several options have been put forward, which can explain the given paradox. What kind of water freezes faster, hot or cold, may depend on the fact that it has a bigger than that of cold, the rate of evaporation. Thus, its volume decreases, and with a decrease in the volume and the time of freezing it becomes less than if you take a similar initial amount of cold water.

For a long time they defied the freezer

What kind of water freezes faster, and why this happens, may affect the snow lining, which can occur in the freezer of the refrigerator used for the experiment. If you take two containers identical in volume, but in one of them there will be hot water, and in the other - a cold, container with hot water melts under it snow, thereby improving the heat level contact with the wall of the refrigerator. Cold water container cannot do this. If there is no such lining with snow in the refrigeration chamber, cold water should freeze faster.

The top is down

Also the phenomenon of what water freezes faster - hot or cold, explained as follows. Following certain laws, the cold water freeze starts from the upper layers when hot does it on the contrary - it starts to freeze from the bottom up. At the same time, it turns out that cold water, having a cold layer with already in places formed ice, the processes of convection and thermal radiation impairs themselves, thereby explain what water freezes faster - cold or hot. Photos from amateur experiments attached, and here it is clearly visible.

Heat comes out, striving up, and there is found with a very cooled layer. There is no free path for heat emission, because the cooling process becomes difficult. Such obstacles on their path absolutely no hot water. What freezes faster - cold or hot, from which the likely outcome depends, it is possible to expand the answer to the fact that any water has certain substances dissolved in it.

Impurities in the composition of water as a factor affecting the outcome

If you do not cheat and use water with the same composition, where the concentrations of certain substances are identical, then cold water should freeze faster. But if the situation occurs when dissolved chemical elements are in stock only in hot water, and the cold water does not have them, then there is an opportunity for hot water to frozen before. It is explained by the fact that dissolved substances in water create crystallization centers, and with a small amount of these centers, the conversion of water into solid state is difficult. It is possible even the supercooling of water, in the sense that at a minus temperature it will be in a liquid state.

But all these versions, it can be seen, did not fully arrange scientists and they continued to work on this issue. In 2013, a team of researchers in Singapore stated that they managed to solve a century-old riddle.

A group of Chinese scientists argues that the secret of this effect consists in the amount of energy that is stored between water molecules in its bonds referred to as hydrogen.

Riprage from Chinese scientists

Next will follow information, to understand which you need to have some knowledge in chemistry to understand what water freezes faster - hot or cold. As is known, consists of two H (hydrogen) atoms and one atom of (oxygen) held between themselves covalent bonds.

But also hydrogen atoms of one molecule are attracted to neighboring molecules, to their oxygen component. These are supposedly called hydrogen.

It should be remembered that at the same time water molecules act on each other repellent. Scientists noted that when heated water between its molecules, the distance is increasing, and this is promoted just repulsive forces. It turns out that occupying one distance between molecules in a cold condition, it can be said stretched, and they have a greater supply of energy. It is this stock of energy that is released when the water molecules begin to come close to each other, that is, cooling occurs. It turns out that the larger supply of energy in hot water, and its greater release during cooling to minus temperatures, is faster than in cold water, which has a lot of energy. So what water freezes faster - cold or hot? On the street and in the laboratory there should be a paradox of scum, and hot water should turn into ice faster.

But the question is still open

There is only theoretical confirmation of this attenuation - all this is written by beautiful formulas and seems plausible. But when these experiments, what water freezes faster - hot or cold, will be delivered in a practical sense, and their results will be presented, then it will be possible to consider the question of the Paradox of the MPEMBI closed.

Mpemba effect (Paradox of MPEMBI) - a paradox that says that hot water at some conditions freezes faster than cold, although it must undergo the temperature of the cold water in the freezing process. This paradox is an experimental fact that contradicts the usual ideas, according to which, with the same conditions, the more heated body for cooling to a certain temperature requires more time than the less heated body for cooling to the same temperature.

This phenomenon was noticed at one time Aristotle, Francis Bacon and Rene Descart, but only in 1963, Tanzanian schoolboy Erassto Mpembea found that the hot mixture of ice cream freezes faster than cold.

Being a student Magambaba high School In Tanzania, Erasto Mpemba did practical work on the cook case. He needed to make homemade ice cream - boil milk, dissolve sugar in it, cool it to room temperatureAnd then put in the fridge for freezing. Apparently, MPembba was not particularly a diligent student and priedered with the fulfillment of the first part of the task. Fearing that he would not have time for the end of the lesson, he put in the refrigerator still hot milk. To his surprise, it froze even earlier than the milk of his comrades cooked according to a given technology.

After that, MPEMBA experimented not only with milk, but also with ordinary water. In any case, already as a student of the Mkvava high school, he asked the question of Professor Dennis Osborne from the University College in Dar Es Salama (to read the students a lecture on physics in the university classroom: "If you take two identical containers with equal volumes of water So, in one of them, water has a temperature of 35 ° C, and in the other - 100 ° C, and put them in the freezer, then in the second water freezes faster. Why? " Osborne became interested in this issue and soon in 1969, together with Mpemba published the results of their experiments in the magazine "Physics Education". Since then, the effect found is called the effect of Mpemba.

Until now, no one knows how to explain this strange effect. Scientists have no single version, although there are many. It's all about the difference in the properties of hot and cold water, but it is not yet clear which properties play a role in this case: the difference in supercooling, evaporation, ice formation, convection or the effects of discharged gases on water at different temperatures.

The paradoxicality of the effect of the MPEMBA is that the time during which the body cools up to the ambient temperature should be in proportion to the difference in the temperatures of this body and the environment. This law was still established by Newton and since then many times confirmed in practice. In this effect, water with a temperature of 100 ° C cools to a temperature of 0 ° C faster than the same amount of water with a temperature of 35 ° C.

Nevertheless, it does not imply a paradox, since the effect of the MPEMBA can be found an explanation and within the framework of the famous physics. Here are a few explanations of the effect of MPEMBA:

Evaporation

Hot water faster evaporates from the container, thereby reducing its volume, and the smaller volume of water with the same temperature freezes faster. Heated to 100 with water loses 16% of its mass during cooling to 0 C.

Effect of evaporation - double effect. First, the mass of water is reduced, which is necessary for cooling. And secondly, the temperature is reduced due to the fact that the heat of evaporation of the transition from the water phase to the steam phase is reduced.

Temperature difference

Due to the fact that the temperature difference between hot water and cold air is more - therefore heat exchange in this case there is more intense and hot water is cooled faster.

Supercooling

When the water is cooled below 0 C It does not always freeze. Under some conditions, it can undergo hypothermia, continuing to remain liquid at temperatures below the temperature of the freezing point. In some cases, water can remain liquid even at a temperature of -20 C.

The reason for this effect is that in order to begin to form the first ice crystals need crystal formation centers. If they are not in liquid water, then the supercooling will continue until the temperature decreases so much that the crystals will begin to form spontaneously. When they begin to form in a supercooled fluid, they will begin to grow faster, forming a Lorth Shuhuh, which freezing will form ice.

Hot water is most susceptible to supercooling since its heating eliminates dissolved gases and bubbles, which in turn can serve as centers for the formation of ice crystals.

Why does the supercooling cause hot water to stick faster? In the case of cold water, which is not overcooked by the following. In this case, the thin layer of ice will be formed on the surface of the vessel. This layer of ice will act as an insulator between water and cold air and will prevent further evaporation. The rate of formation of ice crystals in this case will be less. In the case of hot water, undergoing supercooling, supercooled water does not have a protective surface layer of ice. Therefore, it loses heat much faster through open top.

When the process of hypothermia ends and water freezes, much more heat is lost and therefore more ice is formed.

Many researchers of this effect consider supercooling to the main factor in the case of the MPEMB effect.

Convection

Cold water begins to freeze from above, thereby worsening the processes of heat emission and convection, and therefore heat loss, while hot water begins to freeze from below.

This effect of water density anomaly is explained. Water has a maximum density at 4 C. If cooling water to 4 s and put it at a lower temperature, the surface layer of water will freeze faster. Because this water is less dense than water at a temperature of 4 s, it will remain on the surface, forming a thin cold layer. Under these conditions, the thin layer of ice will be formed on the surface of the water for a short time, but this layer of ice will be an insulator that protects the lower layers of water, which will remain at a temperature of 4 C. Therefore, the further cooling process will be slower.

In the case of hot water, the situation is completely different. The surface layer of water will be cooled faster due to evaporation and greater temperature difference. In addition, cold water layers are more dense than hot water layers, therefore the cold water layer will fall down, lifting a layer of warm water to the surface. Such water circulation provides a rapid drop in temperature.

But why does this process do not reach the equilibrium point? To explain the effect of the motion from this point of view of convection, it would be necessary to adopt that cold and hot water layers are separated and the convection process itself continues after average temperature Water drops below 4 S.

However, there are no experimental data that would confirm this hypothesis that cold and hot water layers are divided during convection.

Dissolved gases

Water always contains gases dissolved in it - oxygen and carbon dioxide. These gases have the ability to reduce water freezing point. When the water is heated, these gases are released from water, since their solubility in water at high temperatures below. Therefore, when hot water is cooled, there are always fewer dissolved gases in it than in non-heated cold water. Therefore, the freezing point of heated water is higher and it freezes faster. This factor is sometimes considered as the main thing when explaining the effect of the MPEMB, although there are no experimental data confirming this fact.

Thermal conductivity

This mechanism can play a significant role when water is placed in the freezer of the refrigeration chamber in small containers. Under these conditions, it is noted that the hot water container is shifted by a freezer ice from a freezer, thereby improving thermal contact with the freezer wall and thermal conductivity. As a result, the heat is removed from the container with hot water faster than from cold. In turn, the container with cold water does not shive below the snow.

All these (as well as others) conditions were studied in many experiments, but a unambiguous answer to the question - which of them provide one hundred percent reproduction of the MPEMBE effect - and was not received.

For example, in 1995, the German physicist David Auerbach studied the effect of water hypothermia on this effect. He found that hot water, reaching a supercooled state, freezes at a higher temperature than the cold, which means faster the latter. But cold water reaches a supercooled state faster than hot, thereby compensating for the previous lag.

In addition, the results of Auerbakh contradicted the data obtained earlier that hot water is capable of achieving greater overcooling due to a smaller number of crystallization centers. When the water is heated from it, the gases dissolved in it are removed, and during its boiling, some salts dissolved in it are precipitated.

You can say so far only one thing is possible - the reproduction of this effect significantly depends on the conditions in which the experiment is carried out. It is precisely because it is not always reproduced.

O. V. Mosin

Literarysources:

"Hot Water Freezes Faster Than Cold Water. Why Does It Do SO?", Jearl Walker in The Amateur Scientist, Scientific American, Vol. 237, No. 3, pp 246-257; September, 1977.

"The Freezing Of Hot and Cold Water", G.S. Kell in American Journal of Physics, Vol. 37, No. 5, pp 564-565; May, 1969.

"SuperCooling and The Mpemba Effect", David Auerbach, In American Journal of Physics, Vol. 63, No. 10, pp 882-885; Oct, 1995.

"The MPemba Effect: The Freezing Times Of Hot and Cold Water", Charles A. Knight, in American Journal of Physics, Vol. 64, No. 5, p 524; May, 1996.

21.11.2017 11.10.2018 Alexander Feri

« What water freezes faster cold or hot?"- try to ask a question with your familiar, most likely most of them will answer that cold water freeze faster - and make a mistake.

In fact, if you simultaneously put two models in the freezer and volume of the vessel, in one of which there will be cold water, and in a different one, then hot water will be frown faster.

Such an approval may seem absurd and unreasonable. If you follow logic, then hot water should first cool down to the temperature of the cold, and the cold at that time should already turn into a lot.

So why is hot water overtakes cold on the way to freezing? Let's try to figure out.

History of observations and research

Paradoxical effect people have observed for a long time, but no one attacked him much importance. So not docked in the speed of frozen cold and hot water noted in his records arrest, as well as Rene Descartes and Francis Bacon. An unusual phenomenon was often manifested in everyday life.

For a long time, the phenomenon did not have been studied and did not make much interest among scientists.

The beginning of the study of an unusual effect was found in 1963 when an inquisitive schoolboy from Tanzania - Erasto Mpembea, noticed that hot milk for ice cream freezes faster than cold. In the hope of obtaining an explanation of the causes of an unusual effect, the young man asked his physician teacher at school. However, the teacher only laughed at him.

Later, MPemba repeated the experiment, but in his experience, he used no longer milk, and the water and paradoxical effect repeatedly repeatedly.

After 6 years - in 1969, Mpembea asked this question to Professor Physician Dennis Osborne who came to his school. Professor interested in observation of the young man, as a result, an experiment was conducted, which confirmed the effect of the effect, but there was no causes of this phenomenon.

Since then, the phenomenon was called the effect of Mpemba.

In the entire history of scientific observations, a variety of hypotheses on the causes of the phenomenon were put forward.

So in 2012, the British royal chemical society would be announced a contest of hypotheses explaining the effect of the MPEMBA. In the competition, scientists from around the world participated, 22,000 were registered scientific work. Despite such an impressive number of articles, none of them made clarity into the paradox of the MPEMB.

The most common version was performed according to which, hot water freezes faster, as it just evaporates faster, it becomes less, and as the volume decreases, its cooling speed increases. The most common version was eventually refuted as an experiment was conducted, in which evaporation was excluded, and the effect was nevertheless confirmed.

Other scientists believed that the cause of the effect of the MPEMBA is to evaporate dissolved in water gases. In their opinion, in the process of heating the gases dissolved in water are evaporated, due to which it takes on a higher density than the cold. As you know, the increase in density leads to a change physical properties water (increasing thermal conductivity), and consequently an increase in the cooling rate.

In addition, a number of hypotheses were put forward, which describe the rate of water circulation, depending on the temperature. In many studies, an attempt was made to establish the relationship between the container material in which the liquid was located. Very many theories seemed very believable, but scientifically confirm them did not succeed due to the lack of initial data, contradictions in other experiments, or due to the fact that the identified factors were simply not comparable with the speed of cooling the water. Some scientists in their works questioned the existence of the effect.

In 2013, researchers from Technological University Nanyang in Singapore stated that they solved the mystery of the effect of the MPEMBA. According to the research conducted by them, the cause of the phenomenon lies in the fact that the amount of energy stored in hydrogen bonds between the cold and hot water molecules is significantly different.

Computer simulation methods have shown the following results: the higher the water temperature, the larger the distance between molecules due to the fact that the repelling forces increase. And in consequently, hydrogen bonds of molecules are stretched, a substantial amount of energy. When cooled, the molecules begin to close with each other, releaseing energy from hydrogen bonds. In this case, the return of energy is accompanied by a decrease in temperature.

In October 2017, Spanish physicists, during the next study, found out that a large role in the formation of the effect plays exactly the removal of a substance from equilibrium ( strong heating Before a strong cooling). They determined the conditions at which the probability of the effect of the effect is maximum. In addition, scientists from Spain confirmed the existence of the reverse effect of the MPEMB. They revealed that when heated, a colder sample can achieve high temperatures faster than warm.

Despisable information and numerous experiments, scientists intend to continue learning the effect.

MPEMBA effect in real life

And you thought about it, why in winter the roller is poured with hot water, and not cold? As you already understood, do it because the roller filled with hot water will frozen faster than if it was filled with cold. For the same reason, the slides in the winter ice towns are filled with hot water.

Thus, knowledge of the existence of a phenomenon allows people to save time in the preparation of sites for winter sports.

In addition, the effect of the scan is sometimes used in industry - to reduce frost products, substances and materials containing water.

This is true, although it sounds incredible, because in the process of freezing, the warm water must pass the temperature of the cold water. Meanwhile, this effectshire is used. For example, rollers and slides in winter poured hot, not cold water. Specialists advise motorists to fill in winter in the washer tank cold, and not hot water. Paradox is known in the world as the "MPEMB effect".

This phenomenon mentioned Aristotle, Francis Bacon and René Descartes, but only in 1963, professors of physics were paid to him and tried to explore. It all started with the fact that Tanzanian schoolboy Erasto Mpembba noted that sweetened milk, which he used to prepare ice cream, freezes faster if it was pre-heated and put forward the assumption that hot water freezes faster than cold. He appealed for clarification to the physics teacher, but he only laughed at the student, saying the following: "This is not a world physics, but a physician of MPEMS."

Fortunately, Dennis Osborne was once at school, Professor of Physics from the University of Dar Es Salama. And Mpemba appealed to him with the same question. The professor was set up less skeptical, said he could not judge what he had never seen, and upon returning home asked employees to conduct relevant experiments. Looks like they confirmed the words of the boy. In any case, in 1969, Osborne spoke about working with Mpembo in the magazine "Eng. Physics.Education." In the same year, George Kell from the Canadian National Research Council published an article with a description of the phenomenon in "Eng. American.Journalof.Physics.».

There are several options for explaining this paradox:

Hot water evaporates faster, thus reducing its volume, and a smaller volume of water with the same temperature freezes faster. In hermetic containers, cold water should freeze faster.
The presence of snow lining. The hot water container is shoaling under itself, it is therefore thermal contact with a cooling surface. Cold water does not shine under it. In the absence of snow lining, the cold water container must freeze faster.
Cold water begins to freeze from above, thereby worsening the processes of heat emission and convection, and therefore heat loss, while hot water begins to freeze from below. With additional mechanical stirring of water in containers, cold water should freeze faster.
The presence of crystallization centers in cooled water - substances dissolved in it. With a small number of such centers in cold water, the transformation of water into the ice is difficult and possibly its supercooling when it remains in a liquid state, having a minus temperature.

Recently, another explanation was published. Dr. Jonathan Katz (Jonathan Katz) from the University of Washington explored this phenomenon and concluded that dissolved substances dissolved in water are played in it, which are precipitated when heated.
Under dissolved substances Dr. Katz implies calcium and magnesium bicarbonates, which are contained in rigid water. When the water is heated, these substances are deposited, water becomes soft. Water that has never heated, contains these impurities, it is "tough." As it freezes and the formation of ice crystals, the concentration of impurities in water increases 50 times. Because of this, the water freezing point is reduced.

This explanation does not seem convincing, because No need to forget that the effect was found in experiments with ice cream, and not with rigid water. Most likely the cause of the phenomenon of thermophysical, and not chemical.

While the unequivocal explanation of the paradox of the MPEMB is not received. I must say that some scientists do not consider this paradox worthy of attention. However, it is very interesting that a simple schoolboy has achieved recognition of the physical effect and gained popularity due to its curiosity and perseverance.

Added in February 2014

The note was written in 2011. Since then, new studies of the effect of MPEMBI and new attempts to explain it have appeared. So, in 2012, the Royal Chemical Society of Great Britain announced an international competition for the solution of scientific secrets "MPEMBI effect" with a prize fund of 1000 pounds. Deadline was installed on July 30, 2012. Nikola Beregovik from the laboratory of the University of Zagreb became the winner. He published his work in which he analyzed previous attempts to explain this phenomenon and concluded that they were not convincing. The model proposed by them is based on the fundamental properties of water. Those who wish can find a job on the link http://www.rsc.org/mpemba-competition/mpemba-winner.asp

Research on this was not completed. In 2013, Physics from Singapore theoretically proved the cause of the Empube effect. The work can be found by reference http://arxiv.org/abs/1310.6514.

Similar on the subject of articles on the site:

Comments:

Alexey Mishnev. 06.10.2012 04:14.

Why is hot water evaporates faster? Scientists, almost proven that a glass of hot water freezes faster than cold. Scientists this phenomenon cannot explain due to the fact that they do not understand the essence of phenomena: warmth and cold! Heat and cold, this is a physical sensation that causes the interaction of particles of matter, in the form of a counter compression of magnetic waves, which move from the side of the space and from the center of the Earth. Therefore, the greater the difference in potentials, this magnetic voltage, the faster the energy exchange is carried out by the method of counter penetration of some waves to others. That is, diffusion method! In response to my article, one opponent writes: 1) ".. The angry water evaporates faster, as a result of which it remains less, so it freezes it faster" the question! What energy makes the water fire to evaporate faster? 2) In my article talk about a glass, and not about a wooden trough, which the opponent leads as a counterragement. What is not correct! I answer the question: "For what reason are water in nature evaporates?" Magnetic waves, which are always moving from the center of the Earth into space, overcoming the oncoming pressure of magnetic compression waves, (which always move from the space to the center of the Earth) at the same time, spray water particles, as moving into space, they increase in volume. That is, expand! In the case of overcoming magnetic compression waves, these water pairs are compressed (condensed) and under the action of these magnetic compression forces, water in the form of precipitation returns to Earth! With respectful6m! Alexey Mishnev. October 6, 2012.

Alexey Mishnev. 06.10.2012 04:19.

What is the temperature. Temperature is the degree of electromagnetic voltage of magnetic waves with compression and expansion energy. In the case of the equilibrium state of these energies, the body temperature or substance is in a stable state. In disruption of the equilibrium state of these energies, in the direction of the extension energy, the body or substance increases in the amount of space. In case of exceeding the energy of magnetic waves toward compression, the body or substance decreases in the volume of space. The degree of electromagnetic voltage is determined by the degree of expansion or compression of the reference body. Alexey Mishnev.

Moiseeva Natalia23.10.2012 11:36 | VNIIM

Alexey, you talk about some kind of article in which your considerations about the concept of temperature are set out. But nobody read it. Please give a link. In general, your views on physics are very peculiar. I never heard about the "electromagnetic expansion of the reference body".

Yuri Kuznetsov, 04.12.2012 12:32

The hypothesis is proposed that it employs intermolecular resonance and generated by a ponderomotor attraction between molecules. In cold water, the molecules move and fluctuate chaotic, with a different frequency. When water heating, with an increase in the frequency of oscillations, their range is narrowed (the frequency difference from liquid hot water is reduced to the vaporization point), the frequency of oscillations of molecules is approaching each other, as a result of which resonance arises between molecules. When cooling, this resonance is partially saved, not immediately fastened. Try to press one of the two strings of the guitar located in the resonance. Now let go - the string will begin to vibrate again, the resonance will restore its oscillations. So in freezed water, the outer cooled molecules are trying to lose the amplitude and the frequency of oscillations, but the "warm" molecules inside the vessel "pull out" the oscillations back are in the role of vibrators, and outdoor resonators. Between vibrators and resonators and there is a ponderomotor attraction *. When the ponderomotor force becomes greater force caused by the kinetic energy of molecules (which not only vibrate, but also move linearly), accelerated crystallization occurs - the "MPEMBA effect". Pedomotor communication is very unsubstantial, MPEMBA effect strongly depends on all concomitant factors: the volume of frozen water, the nature of it is heating, the conditions of freezing, temperature, convection, heat exchange conditions, gas saturation, vibration of the refrigeration unit, ventilation, impurities, evaporation, etc. Even from lighting ... Therefore, the effect has a lot of explanations and it, sometimes it is difficult to reproduce. According to the same "resonant" reason boiled water It boils fasterly inciphesiated - resonance some time after boiling preserves the intensity of oscillations of water molecules (loss of energy during cooling mainly falls on the loss of the kinetic energy of the linear movement of molecules). With intensive heating, the vibrators molecules are changing with rollers with resonators molecules in comparison with freezing - the frequency of vibrators is less than the frequency of the resonators, and this means that there is no attraction between molecules, and the repulsion that accelerates the transition to another aggregate state (steam).

Vlad, 11.12.2012 03:42

Broke the brain ...

Anton, 02/04/2013 02:02

1. Does this ponderomotor attraction on so large that affects the heat exchange process? 2. Does this mean that when heated all bodies to a certain temperature, their structural particles enter the resonance? 3. As a result, when cooling, this resonance disappears? 4. Is this your assumption? If there is a source, specify. 5. According to this theory, the vessel shape will play an important role, and if it is thin and flat, then the difference in the time of freezing will not be great, i.e. You can check it out.

Goodrat, 03/11/2013 10:12 | Metak.

In cold water there are already nitrogen atoms and distances between water molecules closer than hot water. That is, the conclusion: Hot water absorbs nitrogen atoms faster and at the same time it quickly freezes than cold water - it is comparable with ironing iron, as hot water turns into ice and hot iron hardening with fast cooling!

Vladimir, 03/13/2013 06:50

and maybe this is: the density of hot water and ice is less than the density of cold water, and therefore water does not need to change their density, losing some time on it and it freezes.

Alexey Mishnev, 03/21/2013 11:50

Before arguing about resonances, attractions and vibrations of particles, it is necessary to understand and answer the question: what are the forces make particles fluctuate? Since, without kinetic energy, there can be no compression. Without compression, there can be no expansion. Without expansion, there can be no kinetic energy! When, begin to argue about the resonance of the string, you first put the effort that one of these strings began to fluctuate! Arguing about attraction, you first should specify the power that makes these bodies attract! I say that all bodies are compressed by the electromagnetic energy of the atmosphere and which compresses all the bodies, substances and elementary particles with a force of 1.33 kg. Not at cm2, but on an elementary particle. So, how, the pressure of the atmosphere, can not be selective! Not to be confused, with the amount of force!

Dodik, 05/31/2013 02:59

It seems to me that you forgot one truth - "Science begins where the measurements begin." What is the temperature of "hot" water? What is the temperature of "cold" water? The article does not say a word about it. From here you can conclude - the whole article is a dog's nonsense!

Gregory, 06/04/2013 12:17

Dodia, before the article Chushye, it is necessary to think to learn, at least a little. And not only to measure.

Dmitry, 12/24/2013 10:57

Hot water molecules move faster than in the cold, because of this, more dense contact with environmental, they like absorbing the whole cold quickly slowing down.

Ivan, 01/10/2014 05:53

Surprises the emergence of a similar anonymous article on this site. The article is completely unscientific. Both the author and commentators are embarrassing in search of the explanation of the phenomenon, not bothering to find out, and whether the phenomenon is observed in general and if observed, under what conditions. Moreover, there is no agreement that I actually observe! So the author insists on the need to explain the effect of the rapid freezing of precisely hot ice cream, although the effect was discovered from the whole text (and words "in experiments with ice cream") it follows that he himself did not put such experiments. From the embodiments listed in the article, the phenomena can be seen that they described completely different experiments set in different conditions with different aquatic solutions. Both the essence of the explanation and the subjunctive ignition in them suggest that even an elementary check of the ideas expressed. Someone accidentally heard a bourgeing history and resembling his speculative conclusion. Sorry, but this is not physical scientific research, and conversation in the smoking room.

Ivan, 01/10/2014 06:10

Regarding the comments in the article about the fill of the rollers of hot water and the beams of the washer washer cold. Everything is simple in terms of elementary physics. The rink is poured with hot water just because it freezes it slower. The skating rink should be smooth and smooth. Try to fill it with cold water - get bugs and "influx", because Water will be _fasting_ freeze not so much to spread the uniform layer. And heavily and manage to grow smooth layer, and already existing ice and snowy tubercles will melt. With the washer, it is also not difficult too: it makes no sense to pour clean water in the cold - it freezes on the glass (even hot); A hot non-freezing fluid can lead to cracking cold glass, plus the glass will have an increased freezing temperature due to the accelerated evaporation of alcohols on the way to the glass (with the principle of work moonshine all familiar? - Alcohol evaporates, water remains).

Ivan, 01/10/2014 06:34

And in fact, the phenomenon is stupid to ask why two different experiments in different conditions proceed in different ways. If the experiment is pure, then you need to take hot and cold water the same chemical composition - Take pre-cooled boiling water from the same kettle. We pour into identical vessels (for example, thin-walled glasses). We put on the snow, but on the same smooth dry base, for example, a wooden table. And not in the micromorosil, and in a fairly volumetric thermostat - I spent a couple of years ago in the country when there was a stable frosty weather around -25s. Water crystallizes at a certain temperature after recoiling heat crystallization. The hypothesis is reduced to approval that hot water cools faster (this is so, in accordance with classical physics, the heat exchange rate is proportional to the temperature difference), but retains an increased cooler rate even when its temperature comes with the cold water temperature. It is asked than water that cooled to a temperature of + 20c on the street differs from exactly the same water that has cooled to the temperature + 20c per hour before, but in the room? Classical physics (by the way, based on the chatter in the smoking room, and on hundreds of thousands and millions of experiments) says: Yes, the further dynamics of cooling will be the same (only points +20 boiling water will reach later). And the experiment shows the same: when in a glass with originally cold water, there is already a durable ice crust, hot water did not even think to freeze. P.S. To comments by Yuri Kuznetsova. The presence of a certain effect can be considered established when the conditions for its occurrence are described and it is stably reproduced. And when we are not clear what experiments with it is unknown with what conditions, to build the theories of their explanation prematurely and this does not give anything from a scientific point of view. P.P.S. Well, the comments of Alexei Mishneva read without tears of death is impossible - a person lives in some fictional world that has no relation to physics and real experiments.

Gregory, 01/13/2014 10:58

Ivan, I understand, do you refute the effect of the MPEMBA? It does not exist, how do your experiments show? Why is he so famous in physics, and many are trying to explain it?

Ivan, 02/14/2014 01:51

Good afternoon, Gregory! The effect of an unclean experiment exists. But, as you understand, this is not a reason to look for new patterns in physics, but the reason to improve the skill of the experimenter. As I have already noted in the comments, in all those mentioned attempts to explain the "MPEMBI effect" researchers can not even clearly formulate, as precisely and under what conditions they measure. And you want to say that these are experimenter physicists? Do not make me laugh. The effect is not known in physics, but in the accumulating discussions on different forums and blogs, which is now the sea. As a real physical effect (in the sense, as a result of some new physical laws, and not as a consequence of incorrect interpretation or just a myth), people are perceived by people from physics. So there is no reason to speak about the unified physical effect on the results of different experiments set in completely different conditions.

Paul, 02/18/2014 09:59

hmm, guys ... an article for "AIDS info" ... no offense ...;) Ivan in all right ...

Gregory, 02/19/2014 12:50

Ivan, I agree that the sites of the accumulating topics publishing the unverified sensational material are now a lot.? After all, the effect of MPEMBS is still investigated. And examine scientists from universities. For example, in 2013, this effect was examined by a group from the University of Technology in Singapore. Look at the link http://arxiv.org/abs/1310.6514. They believe, found an explanation for this effect. I will not write in detail about the essence of the discovery, but in their opinion the effect is connected with the difference of energies stored in hydrogen bonds.

Moiseeva N.P. , 02/19/2014 03:04.

For all interested studies of the MPEMB effect, I have slightly supplemented the material of the article and led links for which you can familiarize yourself with the latest results (see Text). Thanks for comments.

Ildar, 02.24.2014 04:12 | it makes no sense to list everything

If this effect of MPEMS really takes place, then the explanation must be sought, I think in a molecular water device. Water (as it became known to me from popular science literature) There are not separate H2O molecules, but clusters of several molecules (even tens). With increasing water temperature, the speed of movement of molecules increases, clusters are divided into each other and the valence of molecules do not have time to collect large clusters. The formation of clusters takes a little longer than to reduce the speed of molecules. And since the clusters are smaller, then the formation of a crystal lattice is faster. In cold water, apparently, large enough sustainable clusters prevent the formation of the lattice, it takes some time on their destruction. I saw a curious effect on TV for TV, when cold water is calmly standing in a jar a few hours in the cold remained liquid. But as soon as the bank was taken to hand, that is, a little stronned from the place, the water in the bank immediately crystallized, became opaque, and the bank was bursting. Well, Pop, who shown this effect, explained that the water was consecrated. By the way, it turns out that the water strongly changes its viscosity depending on the temperature. We, as creatures are large, it is imperceptible, and at the level of small (mm and less) racks, and even more than bacteria, the viscosity of water is a very significant factor. This viscosity, I think also sets the dimensions of water clusters.

Gray, 03/15/2014 05:30

everything around that we see this surface characteristics (properties) So we take for energy only that we can measure or prove the existence in any way otherwise a dead end. This phenomenon of the effect of the MPEMBA may explain only a simple object theory that will unite all physical models into a single structure of interaction. In fact, everything is simple

nikita, 06.06.2014 04:27 | car

and how to make the water remains cold ana was not warm when you go in the car!

alexey, 03.10.2014 01:09

But another "discovery", on the go. Water B. plastic bottle Much quickly freezes with an open cork. For the sake of fun put the experiment many times on a strong frost. The effect is obvious. Hello theorists!

Evgeny, 12/27/2014 08:40

The principle of the evaporative cooler. We take two hermetically closed bottles with cold and hot water. We put on the frost. Cold water freezes faster. Now we take the same bottles with cold and hot water and put on the frost. Hot water will freeze faster cold. If we take two basins with cold and hot water, then hot water will freeze much faster. This is due to the fact that we increase contact with the atmosphere. The more intense evaporation, the faster there is a drop in temperature. Here it is necessary to mention the moisture factor. The lower the humidity is the stronger evaporation and more cooling.

gray Tomsk, 01.03.2015 10:55

Gray, 03/15/2014 05:30 - Continuation What you know about the temperature is not all. There is something else. If it is correct to compile a physical model of temperature, it will be the key to describe the energy processes from diffusion, melting and crystallization and to such scales as an increase in temperature with an increase in pressure, increase pressure with an increase in temperature. Even the physical model of the energy of the Sun will be understood from the above. I am in winter. . In the early spring of 20013, looking at the temperature models amounted to a total temperature model. After a couple of months, I remembered the temperature paradox and here I understood ... that my temperature model describes the MPEMBA paradox. It was in May - June 2013. For a year late, but this is for the better. My physical model stop is a frame and it can be shed both forward and backwards and there is a motorcycle activity in it, the most activity in which everything moves. I have 8 school classes and 2 years of school with a repetition of the topic. 20 years have passed. So all kinds of physical models of famous scientists can't attribute, as well as formulas. So sorry.

Andrei, 08.11.2015 08:52

In general, I have the idea why hot water freezes faster cold water. And in my explanations, everything is very simple if you are interested, then write to me in Email: [Email Protected]

Andrey, 08.11.2015 08:58

I apologize I did not mailbox Here is the right email: [Email Protected]

Victor, 12/23/2015 10:37

It seems to me everything is easier, we have the snow, it has evaporated gas, chilled, the duck can be in the frost because it cools faster, that it evaporates and immediately not climbing crystallizes, and the water in the gaseous state cools faster than in liquid)

Beckzhan, 01/28/2016 09:18

If even someone revealed these laws of the world that are associated with these effect, he would not write here. With my point of sight it would not be logical to disclose its secrets to users of the Internet, when he can publish it on the famous scientific journals and prove him personally Before the people. So what will be written about this effect here, all this is not logical.)))

Alex, 02.22.2016 12:48

hi experimenters are right, saying that science begins where ... not measurements, but calculations. "Experiment" - an eternal and indispensable argument for devoid of imagination and linear thinking of everyone offended, now in case E \u003d MC2 - everyone remembers? The speed of molecules departing from cold water into the atmosphere determines the amount by weight of energy from water (cooling - energy loss) the speed of hot water molecules is much higher and carried out - in the square (the speed of cooling the remaining mass of water) is all if you get away from " experimental and remember the basic bases of science

Vladimir, 04/25/2016 10:53 | Meteo

In those times, when Tosol was rare, water from the car cooling system in the unheated garage of autoship after the working day was drained to not defrost the cylinder block or radiator, sometimes both together. In the morning fired hot water. In the lutty frost engines launched without problems. As the lack of hot water poured water from under the tap. The water immediately frozen. The experiment is expensive costly, just as much as it costs to buy and replace the block of cylinders and the Radiator of the car ZIL-131. Whoever believes will check. And MPEMBA experimented on ice cream. In ice cream, crystallization goes differently than in water. Think off to teeth a piece of ice cream and a piece of ice. Most likely it did not freeze, but thickened as a result of cooling. And the fresh water - be it hot or cold freezes at 0 * p. Cold water is fast, and the hot time is needed.

Wanderer, 05/06/2016 12:54 | To Alex

"C" - the speed of light in vacuum E \u003d Mc ^ 2 - formula expressing the equivalence of mass and energy

Albert, 07/27/2016 08:22

First analogy S. solid bodies (There is no evaporation process). Recently soldered copper water pipes. The process is heated gas burner To the melting point of the solder. The heating time of one junction with a clutch is about one minute. Saying one junction with a clutch and in a couple of minutes I realized that I smelled wrong. It took a little scrolling the pipe in the coupling. He began to warm up the burner of the joint again and, to surprise, it took a minute 3-4 to heat the junction to the melting point. How so!? After all, the pipe is still hot and seemingly needed much less energy to heat it to the melting point, but everything turned out to be the opposite. The whole thing in the thermal conductivity, which already has a warm pipe is significantly higher and the border between the heated and cold pipe in two minutes managed to move away from the place of the junction. Now about water. We will operate with the concepts of hot and the floor heated vessel. In the hot vessel, a narrow border of the temperature partition is formed between hot, highly movable particles and low-propelled, cold, which relatively quickly moves from the periphery to the center, because at this border the quick particles quickly give their energy (cooled) by particles on the other side of the border. Since the volume of outer cold particles is greater, then fast particles, giving up thermal energy, can not significantly warm up the outer cold particles. Therefore, the process of cooled hot water occurs relatively quickly. The floor the heated water has a much lower thermal conductivity and the width of the boundary between the floor with heated and cold particles is essentially wider. Displacement to the center of such a wide border occurs significantly more slowly than in the case of a hot vessel. As a result, the hot vessel cools faster than warm. I think you need to trace the process of cooled different temperature water Placing several temperature sensors from the middle to the edge of the vessel.

Max, 11/19/2016 05:07

Checked: In Yamal, in the frost, a pipe with gray water moves and it is necessary to warm it, and there is no cold!

Artem, 09.12.2016 01:25

It is difficult, but I think that cold water is more densely hot even better boiled and there is an acceleration of cooling and i.e. Hot water comes to a temperature cold and overtakes it, and if it takes into account that hot water freezes from the bottom and not at the top as written above, then this accelerates the process.

Alexander Sergeev, 21.08.2017 10:52

There is no such effect. Alas. In 2016, a detailed article was published on the topic in Nature: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/mpemba_effect It is clear from it that with a careful conduct of experiments (if the samples of warm and cold water are the same in everything, except for temperature) the effect is not observed. .

Zaleb, 08/22/2017 05:31

Victor, 10/27/2017 03:52

"It's really so." - If the school did not understand what the heat and the law of energy conservation is. Check simply - for this we need: desire, head, hands, water, refrigerator and alarm clock. And the rollers, as specialists write, wure out (poured) with cold water, and warm - align the chopped ice. And in the washer tank in winter it is necessary to pour the non-freezing fluid, and not water. Water in any case will leave, and cold - faster.

Irina, 01/23/2018 10:58

scientists of the whole world beating over this paradox, starting with the times of Aristotle, and Victor, Zaleb and Sergeev turned out to be the smartest.

Denis, 01.02.2018 08:51

All correctly in the article is written. But the reason is somewhat different. In the process of boiling, the air dissolved in it is evaporated in it. Therefore, with boiling water cooling, as a result, its density will be less than that of the raw water of the same temperature. There are no other reasons for different thermal conductivity in addition to different density.

Zablan, 03/01/2018 08:58 | Zablab.

Irina :), "Scientists of the whole world" on this "paradox" are not fighting, for these scientists this "paradox" is simply no - it is easily checked in well-reproducible conditions. "Paradox" appeared due to the non-reproducible experiments of the African boy of MPEMBU and will divide him like "scientists" :)

Many researchers were put forward and put forward their versions regarding why hot water freeze faster than cold. It would seem that the paradox - after all, in order to frozen, hot water must be cooled to start. However, the fact remains a fact, and scientists explain it in different ways.

Main versions

On the this moment There are several versions that explain this fact:

Since evaporation in hot water is faster, its volume decreases. And the freezing of a smaller amount of water of the same temperature happens faster.
The freezer of the refrigerator has a snow gasket. The container containing hot water is melting the snow. This improves thermal contact with the freezer.
Freezing of cold water, unlike hot, begins on top. In this case, convection and heat emission, and, consequently, the thermal loss deteriorates.
Cold water has crystallization centers - solids dissolved in it. With a small content of them in the water, the examination is difficult, although at the same time its supercooling is possible - when it has a liquid state at a minus temperature.

Although the fairness can be said that this effect is not always observed. Very often frozen cold water happens faster than hot.

At what temperature water freezes

Why does the freezing of water at all? It contains a certain amount of mineral or organic particles. This, for example, there may be very small sand particles, dust or clay. When the air temperature decreases, these particles are centers around which ice crystals are formed.

The role of crystallization nuclei can also perform air bubbles and cracks in the container where water is contained. The rate of such centers is largely affected by the rate of such centers in a lot of such centers - if there are many of them, the liquid freezes faster. Under normal conditions, with normal atmospheric pressureWater turns into a solid state of liquid at a temperature of 0 degrees.

The essence of the effect of MPEMBA

Under the effect of the scum, they understand the paradox, the essence of which is that under certain circumstances, hot water freezes faster than cold. This phenomenon was still noticed by Aristotle and Descartes. Nevertheless, only in 1963, a schoolboy from Tanzania Erasto Mpembert determined that hot ice cream freezes in a shorter time than cold. He did such a conclusion by performing the task of the cook case.

He had to dissolve sugar and choking him, put it, put it for freezing in the refrigerator. Apparently, MPEMBA did not differ in particular diligence and began to fulfill the first part of the task. Therefore, he did not wait for the cooling of milk, and determined it in the refrigerator with hot. He was very surprised when it froze even faster than his classmates who performed work in accordance with the specified technology.

This fact was very interested in a young man, and he began experiments with simple water. In 1969, Physics Education magazine published the results of research and professor Dennis Osborne from University in Dar Es Salame. The effect of MPEMBI was given by the effect. However, today the phenomenon has no clear explanation. All scientists agree that the main role belongs to the differences of the properties of cooled and hot water, but what exactly is unknown.

Singapore version

Physicists of one of Singapore universities also interested the question, what water freezes faster - hot or cold? A team of researchers under the leadership of S. Chzana explained this paradox precisely by the properties of water. Everyone else from school bench is known composition of water - an oxygen atom and two hydrogen atoms. Oxygen to some extent densites electrons from hydrogen, so the molecule is a certain kind of "magnet".

As a result, certain molecules in water are slightly attracted between themselves and combine hydrogen bond. Her strength is many times lower than a covalent bond. Singapore researchers believe that the explanation of the paradox of the scam is just in hydrogen bonds. If the water molecules are accommodated with each other very tight, then such a strong interaction between molecules can deform the covalent bond in the middle of the molecule itself.

But when water is heated, the associated molecules are slightly removed from each other. As a result, in the middle of molecules, there is relaxation of covalent bonds with extensive energy and the transition to the lower energy level. This leads to the fact that hot water begins to boost accelerated. At least, so shown the theoretical calculations that Singapore scientists held.